Table 5. Summary of Guideline Recommendations

________________________________________________________________________________________________________
                               Recommend                    Option                 Recommend against
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
History and physical                              Pain drawing and visual
exam 34 studies          Basic history (B).       analog scale (D).
                         History of cancer/
                            infection (B).
                         Signs/symptoms of
                            cauda equina
                            syndrome (C).
                         History of significant
                            trauma (C).
                         Psychosocial history
                            (C).
                         Straight leg raising
                            text (B).
                         Focused neurological
                            exam (B).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Patient education 14     Patient education        Back school in
studies                     about low back        nonoccupational settings
                            symptoms (B).         (C).
                         Back school in
                            occupational
                            settings (C).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Medication               Acetaminophen (C).       Muscle relaxants (C).        Opioids used >2wks (C).
23 studies               NSAIDs (B).              Opioids, short course (C).   Phenylbutazone (C).
                                                                               Oral steroids (C).
                                                                               Colchicine (B).
                                                                               Antidepressants (C).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Physical treatment       Manipulation of low      Manipulation for patients    Manipulation for patients
methods 42 methods       back during first           with radiculopathy (C).      with undiagnosed
                         month of symptoms (B).   Manipulation for patients       neurologic deficits
                                                     with symptoms >1 month       (D).
                                                     (C).                      Prolonged course of
                                                  Self-application of heat        manipulation (D).
                                                     or cold to low back.      Traction (B).
                                                  Shoe insoles (C).            TENS (C).
                                                  Corset for prevention in     Biofeedback (C).
                                                     occupational setting      Shoe lifts (D).
                                                     (C).                      Corset for treatment (D).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Injections                                        Epidural steroid             Epidural injections for
26 studies                                        injections for radicular        back pain without
                                                  pain to avoid surgery (C).      radiculopathy (D).
                                                                               Trigger point injections
                                                                                  (C).
                                                                               Ligamentous injections
                                                                                  (C).
                                                                               Facet joint injections
                                                                                  (C).
                                                                               Needle acupuncture (D).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Bed rest                                          Bed rest of 2-4 days for     Bed rest >4 days (B).
4 studies                                         severe radiulopathy (D).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Activities and           Temporary avoidance of                                Back-specific exercise
exercise 20 studies         activities that                                       machines (D).
                            increase mechanical                                Therapeutic stretching of
                            stress on spine                                       back muscles (D).
                            (D).
                         Gradual return to
                            normal activities
                            (B).
                         Low-stress aerobic
                            exercise (C).
                         Conditioning exercises
                            for trunk mescles
                            after 2 weeks (C).
                         Exercise quotas (C).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Detection of             If no improvement                                     EMG for clinically obvious
physiologic                 after 1 month,                                        radiculopathy (D).
abnormalities 14            consider:                                          Surface EMG and F-wave
studies                  Bone scan (C).                                           tests (C).
                         Needle EMG and H-                                     Thermography (C).
                            reflex tests to
                            clarify nerve root
                            dysfunction (C).
                         SEP to assess spinal
                            stenosis (C).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
X-rays of L-S spine 18   When red flags for                                    Routine use in first month
studies                  fracture present (C).                                 of symptoms in absence of
                         When red flags for                                    red flags (B).
                         cancer or infection                                   Routine oblique views (B).
                         present (C).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Imaging 18 studies       CT or MRI when cauda     Myelography or CT-           Use of imaging test before
                            equina, tumor,        myleography for              one month in absence red
                            infection, or         preoperative planning (D).   flags (B).
                            fracture stongly                                   Discography or CT-
                            suspected (C).                                     discography (C).
                         MRI text of choice for
                            patients with prior
                            back surgery (D).
                         Assure quality
                            criteria for
                            imaging tests (B).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Surgical                 Discuss surgical                                      Disc surgery in patients
considerations 14           options with                                          with back pain alone,
studies                     patients with                                         no red flags, and no
                            persistent and                                        nerve root compression
                            severe sciatica and                                   (D).
                            clinical evidence                                  Percutaneous discectomy
                            of nerve root                                         less efficacious than
                            compromise after 1                                    chymopapain (C).
                            month of                                           Surgery for spinal
                            conservative                                          stenosis within the
                            therapy (B).                                          first 3 months of
                         Standard discectomy                                      symptoms (D).
                            and microdiscectomy                                Stenosis surgery when
                            of similar efficacy                                   justified by imaging
                            in treatment of                                       test rather than
                            herniated disc (B).                                   patient's functional
                         Chymopapain, used                                        status (D).
                            after ruling out                                   Spinal fusion during the
                            allergic                                              first 3 months of
                            sensitivity,                                          symptoms in the absence
                            acceptable but less                                   of fracture,
                            efficacious than                                      dislocation,
                            discectomy to treat                                   complications of tumor
                            herniated disc (C).                                   or infection (C).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Psychosocial factors     Social, economic, and                                 Referral for extensive
                         psychological factors                                 evaluation/treatment prior
                         can alter patient                                     to exploring patient
                         response to symptoms                                  expectations or
                         and treatment (D).                                    psychosocial factors (D).
________________________________________________________________________________________________________